South Korea has recently declared their intention to compensate breeders of dogs destined for the meat trade, as part of a larger plan to reduce the comsumption of dog meat by 2027.
The move may seem like a step in the right direction, but it has left many unconvinced. Activists fear that those involved in the trade will simply keep asking for more money, which in turn may actually result in more dogs being bred in order to take advantage of the system in place.
Contradictions and concerns
The plan, which was announced by agricultural minister Song Miryeongm, is only a small part of the wider campaign to ban the breeding, butchering and sale of dog meat from 2027 onwards.
Breeders will be entitled to between 225,000 and 600,000 won (the equivalent of 170-450 dollars), for every dog saved from the trade, based on how quickly their business is closed down.
There are additional incentives for those that decide to move towards other agricultural activities, including lower interest loans and financial support to demolish slaughterhouses and restaurants.
The government has allocated 109.5 million won (around 75 million dollars) for the closure of 5,898 businesses, but breeders believe the amount being offered is too low. They are asking for more, with many feeling their freedom to operate as they choose is under attack.
A half victory for animal rights
It seems it isn't just those involved in the trade that have their doubts, with animal activists questioning the real impact of the incentive.
While the plan undoubtedly represents an important move for the welfare of dogs in South Korea, the fear is that increasingly high numbers of puppies will be born, so that breeders can take full advantage of the funds made available by the government.
There is also concern that the transition period, which is due to end in 2027, will not be enough time to arrange the well-managed closure of all the businesses involved.
