I’m Cathia, and I’ve recently started home breeding. I’d love to get your opinions on something that’s been playing on my mind for a while: pain-free anti-bark collars.
I recently discovered that there are anti-bark collars designed to be gentle and non-punitive. They use methods like vibrations or sounds to catch the dog's attention without causing any pain or stress. The idea is to correct the animal's behaviour in a humane and respectful way.
I must admit, I’m in two minds. On one hand, I can see the potential for these collars to help certain dogs who bark excessively and cause a bit of a nuisance for their neighbours. On the other hand, I wonder if these collars are actually effective and whether they are truly an ethical solution.
I’d be really interested to hear about your experiences and opinions on these pain-free bark collars. Have any of you ever used this type of product? How did your dog react? Do you think it’s a good alternative to more traditional methods?
I’d really appreciate any responses. I’m here to learn and get a better understanding of the different approaches to dog training.
Thanks a lot for your time and for sharing!
Kind regards, Cathia
Translated from French
The forum content is sometimes translated from another language, and posts may concern countries with different animal laws. Do your research before making any decisions.
Since the forum is translated by AI, the translations may contain errors.
Just reading through your replies, my feeling is that it looks like an instrument of torture. Mind you, my absolute nightmare before adopting a dog was the idea of them barking all day while I'm at work and getting into trouble with the neighbours—people are becoming less and less tolerant these days. So, I do understand why people look for "magic" solutions to fix it, but having said that, I really don't think this kind of tool should be used for training purposes.
The only situation where I’d ever recommend this collar is for a dog that’s dearly loved but has serious behavioural issues. In that case, it could be a compromise to manage any risk of aggression without having to make a heart-breaking decision for the dog. But other than that, I’ve got no time for this collar at all.
"Choke chains aren't dangerous if used properly; they aren't actually meant to choke. It's supposed to be the sound of the rings that distracts the dog when they pull to go see something. If it's choking the dog, it's being used wrong."
Everyone knows that’s complete rubbish. A basic choke chain is just a chain without a stopper, with different types of links ranging from very smooth to thick ones for the "early stages of training".
The finer the link, the faster it chokes (it’s a simple matter of physics).
Anyone who claims they use it for that "clinking" sound is lying to themselves and everyone else.
Don't confuse them with a slip lead or a martingale. These aren't meant to choke; they’re adjusted—one to guide the dog, and the other for breeds with very slim heads (like sighthounds) who can easily slip out of normal flat collars.
Choke chains aren't dangerous if they're used properly; they aren't actually meant to choke the dog. It’s supposed to be the sound of the rings clinking that distracts them when they pull to go and look at something. As soon as it starts choking them, it's being used incorrectly.
It's funny actually, because my wife and I bought an anti-bark collar for our small dog, but we've never had to use the shock (which is really mild when it's on a low setting anyway); we've only ever needed the beep and vibration modes.
We even use it for training games, and it works quite well. I think people tend to lump these little battery-powered collars in with choke chains, which are the ones that are actually dangerous for the dog. For us, they're worlds apart, and we should really distinguish between the two. 😀
Thanks everyone for your replies.
I’m of the same opinion as you all, really, but I thought it would be interesting to get a few different perspectives. I’d rather understand why my dog is barking first and only use that sort of thing as a last resort.
Thanks again!
Hi,
This sort of device gets in the way of your dog's communication. Dogs bark, some more than others depending on the breed, the individual dog, and their environment. The key is to interpret your dog's barks so you can give the best possible response. Training is usually enough to stop any unnecessary barking. It’s not really a good idea to ban barking altogether; you need to let your dog express when they're stressed, scared, or unhappy, otherwise you won't be able to understand what they're telling you.
Even though these are less harsh than most anti-bark collars, it doesn’t take away the stress of using such a device. The vibrations or sounds stop or reduce barking by startling the dog (which is obviously stressful) or by being unpleasant for them. So, even if there’s no physical pain, the frustration is still very real.
To ensure your dog's well-being, I’d recommend looking into breed traits instead—some breeds naturally bark very little—and working with your dog to reduce any nuisance barking.
Hope this helps,
Amandine.
Hi, personally I’m against those kinds of collars. I think a dog has every right to express themselves and be vocal. It’s like putting a collar on a human to make them talk less because you find them too chatty. Mind you, I don’t know if they actually work well or not...
