I regret adopting a cat

C
Coupsble Icon representing the flag French
Report

Hello

I've just adopted a cat from a local rescue shelter.

I thought about it for a long time — months — with plenty of doubts, because:

- I grew up with cats at my parents' house and then had them when I was in a relationship. I was never particularly attached to them, but I did look after them properly.

- I currently live in a flat with no outdoor access, with my 6-year-old daughter.

As a single mum, I feel guilty about the separation from her dad, about her being an only child, and so on.

That pushed me towards thinking about getting a cat — for her.

I'd told her for a long time that we'd wait until we had a house before getting a cat. But finding a house isn't exactly straightforward. So I eventually talked myself into not waiting...

We went to the rescue on Saturday, then back on Sunday to adopt an 8-year-old female cat.

She's lovely — beautiful, calm, and affectionate. She's clean and well-behaved. She managed perfectly fine on her own yesterday (Monday). But... I've been swamped with anxiety and low mood ever since, because I know it's a mistake. We live in a fairly small flat with limited window access.

The main thing is, I'm a bit of a clean freak. I can't stand bad smells. I don't like the idea of a cat going on the beds, for instance, or even the sofa — because of the smell. And I hate having to find space in our tiny home for all the things a cat needs (toys, cat tree, etc.).

I try to reason with myself — for her sake, for my daughter's sake — but I know deep down that I won't get past this feeling. Knowing I've made a mistake, that I was irresponsible for not thinking it through more carefully.

I got this cat to make my daughter happy, to give her a companion, to ease my own guilt in a way, to give her what so many of her classmates have (a pet — even without a house or a "proper" family setup) — but sharing a small living space with a cat feels like more than I can handle. It makes me tense.

On top of that, I already feel guilty that the cat is alone for at least 10 hours a day. Everyone says it's fine — including the rescue — but deep down, I don't really believe that.

In short, I made a poor judgement call. I'm too set in my ways and too much of a clean freak to have a cat in a flat. And probably too selfish to do it for my daughter's sake.

I wanted to make her happy... and in the end, I think I've caused a lot of harm.

How long do I keep the cat out of guilt — guilt towards her, or towards my daughter?

I'm thinking about returning her to the rescue. It's making me feel awful.

I'm not entirely sure what I'm hoping to get out of posting this. Some opinions, I suppose — even if I know they might be harsh.

Translated from French
icon info

The forum content is sometimes translated from another language, and posts may concern countries with different animal laws. Do your research before making any decisions.

Since the forum is translated by AI, the translations may contain errors.

Loading editor

Write your message and upload a photo if you want to! Please remain courteous in your exchanges.

Your post will be visible to all members of the international Wamiz forum.

56 answers
Sort by:
  • Show previous comments
  • Tania28
    Tania28 Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    Please keep us updated 🙂
    Translated from French
    C
    Coupsble Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    Thank you for your messages, so full of advice and kindness. They’ve really given me food for thought. Perhaps we just need a bit more time. Maybe I’m also feeling a bit fragile at the moment. She’s definitely a sweet girl who deserves to be loved, that’s for sure. Thank you so much.
    Translated from French
    Tania28
    Tania28 Icon representing the flag French
    Report

    Hi @Coupsble

    I think you’re going through a really tough patch in your life at the moment (separation, single mum, an only child).

    It’s hard to see the positives right now, isn’t it?

    I completely understand.

    This little kitty makes your daughter so happy, so get her to help out (feeding her, helping clean the litter tray – I think you can even get tray liners to make clearing out the mess easier).

    As for the bed, you could either keep the door shut or use a throw or a sheet... something you can quickly shake out of the window.

    A pet brings so much to a child’s life.

    Don’t be cross with her; you rescued her from the RSPCA after all.

    Hang in there, and please don't hesitate to post again.

    How about a little photo of her? 👌

    Translated from French
    ?
    Anonymous user Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    I understand what @Meleinalem is saying and I agree with them, but in your case, I would return the cat to the rescue centre straight away before she gets any more settled. Cats are like sponges; she’ll pick up on your own unhappiness and it will stress her out. I honestly don't think you’re cut out for having a cat, especially if all the things you’ve mentioned are bothering you. I’m a bit of a neat freak myself, but I’ve had to learn to let a lot of things go with cats—accepting fur everywhere even though I clean every day, paw prints, them jumping on the table or the bed, coming to sleep with us... basically everything a cat does. Training a cat isn't like training a dog; cats are naturally stubborn and just do what they want. I know you feel guilty, but you’ll feel even worse if you wait. To avoid upsetting your little girl, maybe suggest an alternative like a guinea pig. They're easier to keep in a hutch, even if they do need to come out for a run now and then, and they're much more manageable. Explain to her that the kitty will be miserable being left alone for 10 hours a day and that cats need to be able to go outside (even if that’s not always the case). Sometimes a little white lie is better than a lot of heartache for a child. I’m not judging you because everyone makes mistakes; the important thing is to fix it. I’m sure the kitty will find a better-suited family, I'm certain of it. To own a cat, you really need to have a strong connection with them, especially with those that aren't yours. If you don't have that "feeling", then let it go. But please don’t wait; the longer you leave it, the harder it will be for the cat, your granddaughter, and yourself. That’s just my take on it. I know others might not agree, but you’ll have to weigh it up against the other advice you get.
    Translated from French
    Meleinalem
    Meleinalem Icon representing the flag French
    Report

    Regarding smells: if you get a large enough hooded litter tray with a flap and a filter, there's no smell at all. During my cat’s final years, she had a massive litter tray and she even seemed to enjoy it; she was ever so happy, it was like playing in a sandpit (I should mention my cat wasn't exactly the size of a Maine Coon, but she was quite big, so I wanted her to be comfortable and not feel cramped).

    Also, if you don't want her getting on the beds, there’s definitely a way to get her to understand. My partner is allergic to cat fur, so in her later years, my cat wasn't allowed in the bedrooms. She got the message and would just lie by the door waiting for me while I was still asleep in the morning. Even if the door was left open, she wouldn’t come in (she’d learned what "no" meant and got the hang of the closed doors early on).

    That said, having a cat curl up in your arms, purring and kneading on the sofa, is really lovely, so I’d say it would be a shame to miss out on that kind of affection.

    And I want to say thank you for being willing to rescue this cat! She sounds like such a sweet little girl!

    Translated from French
    Meleinalem
    Meleinalem Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    Hi there, While some cats might struggle in a flat, I think we need to stop assuming that a cat is automatically miserable living indoors. My cat, who passed away just last week, was 16. I got her as a kitten for my 16th birthday, so I was still living at my mum’s at the time. We had a ground-floor garden and an internal courtyard, so the cats were able to go outside. When she was 5, I moved out into a flat-share with my younger brother. There was no garden anymore, just a very narrow balcony and a sunroom. I was terrified and felt so guilty that she wouldn't settle in. But I didn't want to give her up and my mum wouldn't keep her—she was very much a "one-person" cat and was really attached to me—so I took her with me anyway. And it went brilliantly. I moved flats several times over the years, and some of them were really tiny, but I never had any issues with her. She was always so sweet and affectionate. Of course, having some outdoor space would have made her happy, but I don't feel like she was unhappy at all. Just make sure to take the time to play with her if you’re worried she’s bored (it’s so lovely watching a cat play, and it would be a great activity for your daughter to join in with). Do you honestly think she was happier in a cage at the RSPCA or a rescue centre? You’ve probably saved her life, especially since 8-year-old cats aren't at the easiest age to get adopted. They are in that "in-between" stage where people think the cat has already lived a full life, yet they still have a good 10 years or so ahead of them if they stay healthy. And who knows, maybe one day you’ll move into a house and she’ll be even happier then.
    Translated from French
  • 56 comments out of 56

  • Do you have a question? An experience to share? Create a post on our forum!