I regret adopting a cat

C
Coupsble Icon representing the flag French
Report

Hello

I've just adopted a cat from a local rescue shelter.

I thought about it for a long time — months — with plenty of doubts, because:

- I grew up with cats at my parents' house and then had them when I was in a relationship. I was never particularly attached to them, but I did look after them properly.

- I currently live in a flat with no outdoor access, with my 6-year-old daughter.

As a single mum, I feel guilty about the separation from her dad, about her being an only child, and so on.

That pushed me towards thinking about getting a cat — for her.

I'd told her for a long time that we'd wait until we had a house before getting a cat. But finding a house isn't exactly straightforward. So I eventually talked myself into not waiting...

We went to the rescue on Saturday, then back on Sunday to adopt an 8-year-old female cat.

She's lovely — beautiful, calm, and affectionate. She's clean and well-behaved. She managed perfectly fine on her own yesterday (Monday). But... I've been swamped with anxiety and low mood ever since, because I know it's a mistake. We live in a fairly small flat with limited window access.

The main thing is, I'm a bit of a clean freak. I can't stand bad smells. I don't like the idea of a cat going on the beds, for instance, or even the sofa — because of the smell. And I hate having to find space in our tiny home for all the things a cat needs (toys, cat tree, etc.).

I try to reason with myself — for her sake, for my daughter's sake — but I know deep down that I won't get past this feeling. Knowing I've made a mistake, that I was irresponsible for not thinking it through more carefully.

I got this cat to make my daughter happy, to give her a companion, to ease my own guilt in a way, to give her what so many of her classmates have (a pet — even without a house or a "proper" family setup) — but sharing a small living space with a cat feels like more than I can handle. It makes me tense.

On top of that, I already feel guilty that the cat is alone for at least 10 hours a day. Everyone says it's fine — including the rescue — but deep down, I don't really believe that.

In short, I made a poor judgement call. I'm too set in my ways and too much of a clean freak to have a cat in a flat. And probably too selfish to do it for my daughter's sake.

I wanted to make her happy... and in the end, I think I've caused a lot of harm.

How long do I keep the cat out of guilt — guilt towards her, or towards my daughter?

I'm thinking about returning her to the rescue. It's making me feel awful.

I'm not entirely sure what I'm hoping to get out of posting this. Some opinions, I suppose — even if I know they might be harsh.

Translated from French
icon info

The forum content is sometimes translated from another language, and posts may concern countries with different animal laws. Do your research before making any decisions.

Since the forum is translated by AI, the translations may contain errors.

Loading editor

Write your message and upload a photo if you want to! Please remain courteous in your exchanges.

Your post will be visible to all members of the international Wamiz forum.

56 answers
Sort by:
  • Show previous comments
  • C
    Coupsble Icon representing the flag French
    Report

    Abandoning a sick cat... absolutely vile

    Translated from French
    liquid_paper
    Liquid_paper Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    We never found out why Bertrand was abandoned either... maybe it was his kidney failure? Or perhaps he just got lost? (He’s passed away now, by the way.)
    Translated from French
    C
    Coupsble Icon representing the flag French
    Report

    Yes, it is strange.

    Especially since she was found already spayed and with no injuries. She isn't timid either, so she doesn't seem to have been mistreated.

    She’s FIV positive. That might be the reason...

    Or perhaps she’s just got lost.

    Translated from French
    C
    Coupsble Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    She’s so incredibly endearing, she really is. She’s managed to chip away at my constant need for everything to be perfect. It makes me wonder if she’s teaching me a lesson: what’s more important? A bit of affection or a spotless lounge...
    Translated from French
    liquid_paper
    Liquid_paper Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    Haha... in our house, the cats literally eat on the table and get dry food everywhere. We serve their wet food on the table too, and they sleep and play in our beds. The cats have never bothered our guests; even the ones with allergies or the dog lovers end up giving in. Chatouille is always showing off her bum, and Min Ho, who’s a bit wary of strangers, still shows his belly... Bertrand, on the other hand, was terrified of people he didn't know and would just bolt. Once, Chatouille sat right on top of someone allergic to cats and she just cracked—she didn't want to touch her at first but ended up stroking her. *Too tempting!* Your girl seems so lovely, you really have to wonder how on earth she ended up being abandoned...
    Translated from French
    Meleinalem
    Meleinalem Icon representing the flag French
    Report

    Oh my goodness, she looks like such a sweet little thing! I can totally see why you’ve fallen for her!

    Lots of cats absolutely hate being picked up. The fact she’s letting you do that so soon is really quite something, though. She’s definitely the type of cat you get attached to quickly!

    If you do bond with her, I reckon you'll soon look past the cat hair scattered around the flat. And you’ll definitely need to provide something for her to scratch, especially if she’s an indoor cat; it’s hard to do without a cat tree when you're living in a flat. Basically, she needs something of her own where she can play, climb, and sharpen her claws. Cats are actually pretty good at keeping themselves busy if they've got enough to do—otherwise, that’s when they start going for the furniture.

    Mind you, mine has ruined a few things in my time (like the chairs), but I loved my cat so much that the furniture just didn't seem important anymore.

    As for the guests, I’d say unless they aren't "animal people," everyone understands that when you have a pet, your home isn't always going to be pristine.

    Anyway, I just hope the little soul has a happy life, wherever she ends up!

    Translated from French
    C
    Coupsble Icon representing the flag French
    Report

    A photo of the kitty in question

    I only adopted her last Sunday, so I’m giving myself until Sunday at the latest to make my mind up.

    Translated from French
    C
    Coupsble Icon representing the flag French
    Report

    Thank you so much for all your messages; they all make perfect sense. I completely agree with you all that I need to make a decision quickly for the sake of the kitty and my daughter. I’m going to give myself until the end of the week at the latest.

    You're right about one thing: she’s an absolute sweetheart.

    In fact, I really enjoy giving her a cuddle.

    So my reaction seems out of proportion, except for the fact that her presence has triggered some anxieties (feeling overwhelmed, feeling like I’ve failed to provide a better home, etc.).

    This little cat has really shaken things up inside me. I’m realising it’s about much more than just the housework or the flat being too small.

    The fear of my flat not being nice enough or clean enough for guests, and so on...)

    It’s also very possible that I’m focusing on the downsides because I’m scared of the commitment or the lack of space (I’m still struggling with the fact that I no longer have a house or a family life; I haven’t come to terms with the shared custody arrangement yet... etc.).

    I thought I’d moved past certain stages... the next few days will help me see things more clearly and make a decision.

    I sincerely thank you for the quality and kindness of your messages.

    Translated from French
    ?
    Anonymous user Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    You say you think you’re being too selfish to have a cat in the house, but personally, I don’t see it that way at all. I think you’re just being realistic. My daughter is a big animal lover, but only when they belong to other people; she doesn’t really go out of her way to interact with my cats, even though she likes them well enough. She’s a total clean freak, and what you’ve said reminds me so much of her. I know she’ll never have pets of her own—she’s told me as much—and honestly, I think she’s right. I know the animal wouldn't be truly happy, even if it weren't being mistreated, far from it. For her, it would just be a massive burden, and I’m certain she’d end up regretting it. My granddaughter spent ages pestering her for a little dog at one point, but I talked her out of it because I know my daughter just isn't cut out for it. I much prefer someone who recognises that about themselves than someone who gets an animal and doesn't look after it properly or give it the happy life it deserves. You’ve got very different opinions on the matter, which won’t make things any easier for you, but please don't feel guilty. You thought it might work and you made the effort for your daughter’s sake—that isn’t selfishness. But if you realise it’s going to turn your life upside down, especially when things are already a bit chaotic, then don’t make things even harder for yourself.
    Translated from French
    P
    Picatsou Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    Did you adopt them recently? My mum and brother wanted to get a cat, but I was against it because I knew I’d end up being the one looking after her (and sure enough, I was!) and it was the first time I’d ever had a cat. At first, I was almost unsettled and a bit bewildered by her presence during those first few weeks. But now I wouldn't give her up for the world; she’s an integral part of the family.
    Translated from French
  • 50 comments out of 56

    See more
  • Do you have a question? An experience to share? Create a post on our forum!