I regret adopting a cat

C
Coupsble Icon representing the flag French
Report

Hello

I've just adopted a cat from a local rescue shelter.

I thought about it for a long time — months — with plenty of doubts, because:

- I grew up with cats at my parents' house and then had them when I was in a relationship. I was never particularly attached to them, but I did look after them properly.

- I currently live in a flat with no outdoor access, with my 6-year-old daughter.

As a single mum, I feel guilty about the separation from her dad, about her being an only child, and so on.

That pushed me towards thinking about getting a cat — for her.

I'd told her for a long time that we'd wait until we had a house before getting a cat. But finding a house isn't exactly straightforward. So I eventually talked myself into not waiting...

We went to the rescue on Saturday, then back on Sunday to adopt an 8-year-old female cat.

She's lovely — beautiful, calm, and affectionate. She's clean and well-behaved. She managed perfectly fine on her own yesterday (Monday). But... I've been swamped with anxiety and low mood ever since, because I know it's a mistake. We live in a fairly small flat with limited window access.

The main thing is, I'm a bit of a clean freak. I can't stand bad smells. I don't like the idea of a cat going on the beds, for instance, or even the sofa — because of the smell. And I hate having to find space in our tiny home for all the things a cat needs (toys, cat tree, etc.).

I try to reason with myself — for her sake, for my daughter's sake — but I know deep down that I won't get past this feeling. Knowing I've made a mistake, that I was irresponsible for not thinking it through more carefully.

I got this cat to make my daughter happy, to give her a companion, to ease my own guilt in a way, to give her what so many of her classmates have (a pet — even without a house or a "proper" family setup) — but sharing a small living space with a cat feels like more than I can handle. It makes me tense.

On top of that, I already feel guilty that the cat is alone for at least 10 hours a day. Everyone says it's fine — including the rescue — but deep down, I don't really believe that.

In short, I made a poor judgement call. I'm too set in my ways and too much of a clean freak to have a cat in a flat. And probably too selfish to do it for my daughter's sake.

I wanted to make her happy... and in the end, I think I've caused a lot of harm.

How long do I keep the cat out of guilt — guilt towards her, or towards my daughter?

I'm thinking about returning her to the rescue. It's making me feel awful.

I'm not entirely sure what I'm hoping to get out of posting this. Some opinions, I suppose — even if I know they might be harsh.

Translated from French
icon info

The forum content is sometimes translated from another language, and posts may concern countries with different animal laws. Do your research before making any decisions.

Since the forum is translated by AI, the translations may contain errors.

Loading editor

Write your message and upload a photo if you want to! Please remain courteous in your exchanges.

Your post will be visible to all members of the international Wamiz forum.

56 answers
Sort by:
  • Show previous comments
  • C
    Coupsble Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    @Ulalie: yes, she’s in her new home today and we’re going to get on brilliantly. I’m working from home today and I really enjoy having her company. I never thought I’d be asking myself so many existential questions when she arrived 😅 but it probably shows that I really need to find some peace of mind again. Just like Bigoudie. It’s been a lovely encounter that’s already taught me quite a lot in just a few days 😌
    Translated from French
    C
    Coupsble Icon representing the flag French
    Report

    @Yume: that's exactly what I keep telling myself... I'm overthinking everything and putting so much pressure on myself to stay on top of it all, housework included...

    This little furball is going to teach me how to let go a bit and just enjoy things instead of stressing out.

    Translated from French
    Soil
    Soil Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    Oh wow! I’ve absolutely loved this thread :D I’m so pleased you’ve found some common ground and that you let your hearts make the decision for you. All the best to the three of you :)
    Translated from French
    ?
    Anonymous user Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    She’s such a sweetheart! She looks so settled in with you and already very spoilt. I love the name Bigoudie; it’s adorable and suits her down to the ground. It wouldn’t surprise me if she’d lived with an elderly person, seeing as she’s so chilled out. I adopted an older cat myself whose owner had gone into a care home. He’s a total sweetheart too. In his case, the family handed the cats over to a local rescue, but some people have no qualms about just chucking them out on the street, telling themselves that a cat can fend for itself. It’s awful how some people are happy to take the inheritance when someone passes away, but just turn the pets out. Anyway, I’m so chuffed she’s found a new forever home; I’m really happy for both her and you.
    Translated from French
    Yume
    Yume Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    Hello. Thank you so much for such a lovely adoption, and I’m sure everything will go really well. Seeing how much you already adore them, the little downsides that come with having a pet will soon start to matter much less. Perhaps it’ll even encourage you to be a bit less of a clean freak and feel more relaxed about it all (just don’t end up as messy as me!).
    Translated from French
    C
    Coupsble Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    @meleinalem: I quite agree with you. It really surprises me that she was abandoned, considering her behaviour. I was just told that the pound handed her over to the RSPCA back in January.
    Translated from French
    C
    Coupsble Icon representing the flag French
    Report

    I really wanted to say a huge thank you to everyone.

    Bigoudie has a second chance because I went to the rescue, but also because you were there to give me advice, reassure me and support me through the whole adoption process.

    You’ve really helped us, thank you 🙏

    Translated from French
    C
    Coupsble Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    Hi everyone, Her name is Bigoudie. My daughter and I kept her name because it’s lovely; it’s part of her history and, more importantly, she really responds to it. Day 4 My daughter and I were able to spend plenty of time with her this afternoon. She's like a dog in a cat's body... honestly. I've never known anything like it with other cats. She’s so calm... (Except if you accidentally touch her belly. She was spayed recently and it seems to have been a bit traumatic for her as she really bites. Hard enough to draw blood... So we have to be careful with that and respect her fear.) Other than that, everything is going well. We’re all settling in together nicely 😊. She’s certainly a spoilt little thing; I’d already bought some bits, but a friend also gave me loads of stuff, including a cat tree. At the moment, her favourite spot is my bench right by the sunny window 😊.
    Translated from French
    Meleinalem
    Meleinalem Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    I'd already heard about the "one tray per cat plus one" rule, but I didn't even know that two litter trays were recommended for just one cat. My cat never had any accidents outside of her single tray, even when I was away. Towards the end of her life, I invested in a large litter tray (actually one meant for Maine Coons), as I felt she wasn't particularly comfortable in a standard-sized one, and as she got older there were a few mishaps (bits being kicked out). The large tray sorted the problem right out. Plus, she had a whale of a time scratching around in it! On the other hand, my mum's cats are very fussy: as soon as the tray is soiled, it has to be cleaned, otherwise, the next time they need to go it's on the floor or, worse, on her bed... I think it really just depends on the cat, to be honest. I'm really moved to read that you've decided to keep her after all. It's so heart-warming because you're really giving this little one a second chance. It doesn't surprise me that she comes when you call her; mine used to do the same. She must have already had a lovely bond with her previous owner, but I'm surprised she lost them if she's so sociable (was she really abandoned? Or did she just get lost and the owner hadn't bothered to have her microchipped or tattooed? Or perhaps the owner passed away?).
    Translated from French
    Blue_Cat
    Blue_cat Icon representing the flag French
    Report

    Hi again,

    I’m glad to see you’re feeling a bit more positive now. This little girl clearly loves you already and she sounds really easy-going.

    Personally, I always stick to the "one tray per cat plus one extra" rule. Behaviourists really swear by it. Even if a single cat can often get by with just one tray, it needs to be a large one, uncovered, and kept spotless (bleach the tray every week and scoop out waste as you go). I actually use plastic storage crates that you can pick up in any big supermarket or DIY shop. They’re much bigger than standard litter trays and the high sides help stop them from kicking litter all over the floor.

    I have three indoor cats and haven't had a single issue with house-soiling. I’m convinced that proper litter management is the main reason why. Of course, that’s assuming there are no underlying urinary issues—cystitis can lead to accidents because of the pain. But touch wood, none of mine have suffered from it so far.

    Translated from French
  • 20 comments out of 56

    See more
  • Do you have a question? An experience to share? Create a post on our forum!