I compared 40 types of dry food... and I missed the most important thing

PingouinEmbarrasse6704
Pingouinembarrasse6704 Icon representing the flag French
Report

When Mythie came home, I wanted to do everything perfectly. Mythie – short for Myrtille (Blueberry) because of her blue coat, and "myth" for the quiet elegance of her breed – was my very first pet. Since I work in procurement, evaluating, comparing, and auditing value-for-money is my job. So, I applied myself almost obsessively.
I compared 40 types of dry food... and I missed the most important thing

I spent an entire week scrutinising the ingredients, reviews, and labels of over 40 brands.

The result? I missed the most important thing. I overlooked the calcium-to-phosphorus ratio – a nutritional parameter that is actually vital for the health of Russian Blues. Even worse: the brand I had painstakingly selected had a recent history of mass recalls in the States due to serious cases of paralysis, information that was impossible to find on standard comparison sites here in the UK.

This realisation hit me: the majority of online recommendations are either completely generic or indirectly sponsored by manufacturers. Nothing is truly based on the cat's objective needs, cross-referenced with strict FEDIAF standards.

To cut through this jungle and help me day-to-day, I started developing a small independent tool based on these reference standards, to calculate the optimal combination (especially the wet/dry mix) according to the cat's profile and the owner's actual budget.

The project is still at the prototype stage and I am looking for owners of healthy adult cats – the "top of the class" types when it comes to nutrition – to test the tool's logic and tell me what is missing.

If this approach resonates with you, I have put a page online to explain the project's philosophy and to sign up for the first tests: www.mythienutrilogic.com (it is completely free, I am just looking for some constructive feedback).

Have you also felt like you need a PhD in pet nutrition just to fill a food bowl? How do you manage your ratio calculations on a daily basis?

Translated from French
icon info

The forum content is sometimes translated from another language, and posts may concern countries with different animal laws. Do your research before making any decisions.

Since the forum is translated by AI, the translations may contain errors.

Loading editor

Write your message and upload a photo if you want to! Please remain courteous in your exchanges.

Your post will be visible to all members of the international Wamiz forum.

1 answer
Sort by:
  • ProvetoJuniorConseil
    Provetojuniorconseil Icon representing the flag French
    Expert verified
    Report

    Hello,

    Nutrition is a speciality within veterinary medicine. Even for graduates, it is a truly complex field that is difficult to grasp in its entirety.

    As a vet student, I can tell you that a cat needs a high protein intake (at least 60-65g of crude protein per Mcal of food), preferably from animal sources to limit deficiencies in amino acids (taurine) or essential fatty acids (arachidonic acid). You also need to monitor their daily water intake—about 14 to 23ml per lb (30 to 50ml per kg) per day, including both food and drink—and their calcium-to-phosphorus (Ca/P) ratio should be around 1.3. This remains generic information that may need to be adapted for each individual cat based on a vet's advice.

    I would also recommend speaking to your local vet to evaluate the quality of the dry food. We are trained in the basics of nutrition: ration composition, essential requirements, and balance. Although everyone’s comfort level with the discipline varies, you start to develop a keen eye for it after constantly dealing with various brands, ingredient labels, and marketing campaigns.

    You could also try contacting veterinary nutritionists to get their opinion on your tool.

    Have a good evening,

    Quitterie.

    Translated from French
  • 1 comment out of 1

  • Do you have a question? An experience to share? Create a post on our forum!