My dog killed my other dog

L
Laure359 Icon representing the flag French
Report

Hi everyone,

I really need some advice. My 2-year-old Husky has killed my partner’s dog, a 3-year-old Jack Russell.

We have four dogs: three Jack Russells (one male and two females) and my Husky.

They usually live separately—the two female Jacks live outside in a pen, while the Husky and the male Jack (who is 7 months old) live in the house or outside depending on the weather and what they fancy.

They do have contact, though, as they can see and sniff each other through the wire of the pen.

My Husky is a bit of a tricky character; she’s fine with submissive dogs but she is definitely a dominant type, so as long as another dog doesn’t growl at her, she doesn’t bother them—at least when we're away from the house anyway.

With people, she’s very wary and will only let me and a few people she knows get near her, but even then, that's only at home. When we're out, it’s only me. I’ve had her since she was about 10 or 11 months old.

She’s never attacked other dogs before, except to defend one of mine that was being went for, and one other time when she pinned an off-lead dog that came charging at her growling.

On walks, we let them all out together off-lead and there’s never been a problem; they play together and so on...

My Husky has never had any issues with my male Jack or the other female Jack, except around mealtimes when she absolutely has to be left alone. However, she’s never really liked the female dog she killed; there were never any real fights though, except once when the Jack Russell actually snapped at her over a toy. I told her "no" and grabbed her, and she didn't retaliate.

But today, we let them all out into the yard to play together like we usually do, and my Husky stood over the other dog like she usually does to show she’s the boss. Normally she just does that, has a sniff, and then wanders off, but this time she grabbed her by the neck and shook her violently. I had a lot of trouble getting her to let go—she’s a big girl, over 4 and a half stone (66lbs)—but it was too late, she’d killed her... I could see she’d gone in for the kill; it was so violent and she even tried to go back at her.

What do you think? I’m terrified of letting her near the others now... and when we’re out, I usually have her off-lead (I go hunting and she comes tracking with me, so she’s never on a lead). Could this change her behaviour with other dogs?

I don’t understand why she did it; there was no food around, and the other dogs weren't even close by...

Sorry for the long post, I just wanted to give as much detail as possible.

Thanks in advance.

Translated from French
icon info

The forum content is sometimes translated from another language, and posts may concern countries with different animal laws. Do your research before making any decisions.

Since the forum is translated by AI, the translations may contain errors.

Loading editor

Write your message and upload a photo if you want to! Please remain courteous in your exchanges.

Your post will be visible to all members of the international Wamiz forum.

35 answers
Sort by:
  • Show previous comments
  • ?
    Anonymous user Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    Your problem has nothing to do with your dog being a Husky; this is a behaviour found in every single breed without exception. It also has nothing to do with the fact that you hunt with her, and it won’t change her behaviour towards your other dogs. If you already knew that your dog didn’t get along with the other one, then the outcome was predictable—it was only a matter of time. Two dogs that are incompatible never will be, and they will never become friends. No amount of training can change that, and even if the dogs seem to behave properly together, there will eventually be a spark that sets things off and leads to a tragedy. It takes less than 10 seconds for one dog to kill another. When your dog grabbed that Jack Russell by the neck, she was already dead from the very first shake (a broken neck). With dogs of a similar size, they simply sink their teeth into the neck artery—dogs know exactly where it is. There was nothing you could have done at that moment.
    Translated from French
    L
    Laure359 Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    She definitely has a strong prey drive, but then she is a hunting breed and they're well known for that. But for her to actually go for another dog? Especially since she's absolutely fine with the other two—they love "pestering" her and she’s always really patient and not at all aggressive. I have two cats as well and there's nothing to report there; she ignores them, and even when she wants to play, she’s quite gentle. Maybe the "separation" thing is an angle to explore—like she felt she was on her own territory—but even then, she doesn't do it at all with the other female dog. I've spoken to my partner about it and I'm going to find a local behaviourist to get their take on it... In the meantime, I'm thinking of keeping her separate from my little Jack, but I'm not sure if that's the solution or if it might just cause jealousy... It's a tough one.
    Translated from French
    ?
    Anonymous user Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    Evening... I’ll leave the expert advice to those who know more about dog behaviour than I do, but perhaps there were several factors at play in what happened? Firstly, I think Huskies tend to be a more dominant breed than others towards their own kind, because of their more primitive nature... Then there’s the fact of "hunting" with her and tracking small animals – could that have allowed or even encouraged this behaviour towards "prey"? I’ve also often heard about the Husky’s instinctive prey drive when it comes to sheep or cats, and therefore a little Jack Russell... And finally, perhaps the fact that she was allowed in the house while the other wasn't? She might have felt it was more "her" territory than your Jack's, and in her eyes, he had less right to be there than she did. It’s possible that the combination of all these things led to this tragic accident... I’m sure seeing a dog behaviourist is going to be strongly recommended.
    Translated from French
    L
    Laure359 Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    I’m fairly well-informed about Huskies; I’ve owned one before and never had any trouble with other dogs. Could you explain what you mean by that? Please be patient with me, as I’m here seeking advice. I’m deeply saddened and shocked by what’s happened, and while I may have made some mistakes without realising it, that’s exactly why I’ve come here for help. Thank you.
    Translated from French
    ?
    Anonymous user Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    It was bound to happen! If you’d done your homework on the breed and Husky behaviour, you could have avoided this carnage! All I can tell you is that now he’s two, he isn’t going to stop there! Get in touch with a dog trainer immediately to see if they can salvage your dog’s training, though I doubt they’ll be able to do much! Get your other Jacks to safety!
    Translated from French
  • 35 comments out of 35

  • Do you have a question? An experience to share? Create a post on our forum!