Regression: My dog has started toileting in the flat again

C
Cannibalkat Icon representing the flag French
Report

Hi everyone,

I’m having a bit of a problem with my partner's dog.

To give you some background, the dog is over a year old now. He used to live with my partner and her ex. They basically let him do whatever he wanted for months.

The result: the dog is king of the castle. My partner used to baby him a lot, so now he needs loads and loads of attention and has developed quite a few bad habits.

To sort this out, we got in touch with a dog trainer. They gave us some tips on teaching him to be more independent, to stop pulling on the lead, and not to jump up at people... basically, how to be a well-behaved little dog.

They also explained that for the time being, the dog shouldn't be allowed on the sofa or to sleep in the bed. My partner wanted him there, but it drove me mad because he kept waking us up at night (licking our faces, climbing over us...).

For discipline, they suggested giving him a 10-minute 'time-out' in the bathroom after three naughty things in a row.

Since then, things have been improving bit by bit; we’re managing to correct his behaviour and, more importantly, our own. He pulls less and less on the lead, and he doesn't growl anymore when we go near his food bowl...

BUT... of course, there’s a BUT.

Ever since we started following the trainer's methods, the little guy doesn't even bother going to the toilet outside anymore!

- At night while we’re asleep, he wees or poos on the floor.

- During the day if we go out, he wees on the floor or on the sofa.

- He’s becoming more and more destructive when we’re away.

Before we started the training, we didn't have any issues with this at all.

I don’t know what to do....

We’re seeing the trainer again soon, but I’d love some advice before then. Cleaning up dog mess as soon as I wake up isn't exactly a hobby of mine.

Translated from French
icon info

The forum content is sometimes translated from another language, and posts may concern countries with different animal laws. Do your research before making any decisions.

Since the forum is translated by AI, the translations may contain errors.

Loading editor

Write your message and upload a photo if you want to! Please remain courteous in your exchanges.

Your post will be visible to all members of the international Wamiz forum.

23 answers
Sort by:
  • Jean-Yves
    Jean-yves Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    No, don't punish him every time he gets on the sofa; otherwise, you’ll end up in a constant battle with him, and it’ll just be a case of who loses patience first. At that game, dogs are world champions! ^^ Give him a firm "no" just as he’s thinking about jumping up, not once he’s already started. You need to nip it in the bud, even if you have to physically block his path to the sofa. If he still isn't listening, then you should start from scratch with his obedience, focusing on rewarding the things he does right. To get him to listen, you also need to do a short training session every day, going over the basics he already knows like "sit", "down", and "stand", while introducing new commands like "on your bed" or "stay". A proper "sit" or "down" shouldn't just last a couple of seconds; he needs to hold it for longer and longer. Keep the training sessions short—10 minutes is plenty—but do them every single day. Above all, don't lose your temper. Make sure to reward him properly when he gets a command right, using play, treats, or plenty of praise. Always end each session with a command he’s mastered, and have a good play session both before and after. Front-clip harnesses that stop a dog from pulling are really effective. Personally, the True Love harness was a lifesaver when I broke my foot and my girl was still pulling. Avoid choke chains, as he might just toughen up against it, especially if he’s already got a strong will and is a bit stubborn. Let’s be honest, putting a few cushions in a dog basket is never going to be as comfy as a sofa or a bed. I actually swapped my dog's bed—which she hardly ever used—for this one instead: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Pawhut-Elevated-Dog-Bed-Navy/dp/B07CPQ8FXL It’s really comfy and plush, and it keeps them off the cold floor. I’m really chuffed with this dog bed; plus, the cover comes off easily, is machine washable, and dries in no time.
    Translated from French
    C
    Cannibalkat Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    I'm going to try rewarding him if he gets down on his own.
    Translated from French
    C
    Cannibalkat Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    It’s definitely attention-seeking, that's for sure. But it’s constant... I’ve tried to distract him from the sofa by throwing a ball, playing with him, cuddles etc... but as soon as I stop, he’s straight back jumping on me or the sofa... The intention is 'cute' but in our day-to-day life, my partner and I can’t even have a hug without him jumping all over us, or if I’m working at my desk, he jumps on me non-stop. And now the real issue is getting more serious: he’s becoming aggressive with us when we’re going to bed or when we leave the flat... He actually bit me this morning! I’m trying to stay consistent: if he misbehaves, he goes into the bathroom for a 15-minute time-out. But now he’s trying to bite me when I lead him by his collar (I do it gently so as not to escalate the aggression).
    Translated from French
    C
    Cannibalkat Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    It’s definitely attention-seeking, that's for sure. But it’s constant... I’ve tried to distract him from the sofa by throwing a ball, playing with him, cuddles etc... but as soon as I stop, he’s straight back jumping on me or the sofa... The intention is 'cute' but in our day-to-day life, my partner and I can’t even have a hug without him jumping all over us, or if I’m working at my desk, he jumps on me non-stop. And now the real issue is getting more serious: he’s becoming aggressive with us when we’re going to bed or when we leave the flat... He actually bit me this morning! I’m trying to stay consistent: if he misbehaves, he goes into the bathroom for a 15-minute time-out. But now he’s trying to bite me when I lead him by his collar (I do it gently so as not to escalate the aggression).
    Translated from French
    Kikaah
    Kikaah Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    Instead of constantly telling him off, you should teach him how to get off the sofa. This implies that he’s allowed up, but if he understands that jumping down earns him a treat, he’ll do it much more willingly the next time he’s up there ^^ Could jumping on the sofa actually be an invitation to play?
    Translated from French
    C
    Cannibalkat Icon representing the flag French
    Report

    When I tell him no, I have to get him down, otherwise he tries to chew my watch (the little rascal!).

    He’s stubborn, really stubborn.

    We’ve added some cushions to his bed to make it more comfortable for him.

    Do you think I should be punishing him basically every time he tries it?

    The problem is that at first, he lets me take him to the bathroom, but after a while he gets fed up and growls...

    As for the collar, it breaks my heart, so for now we’re sticking with a standard collar. We’re going to follow the trainer’s advice and use a choke chain if he really won't listen.

    Translated from French
    Kikaah
    Kikaah Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    Instead of using a choke chain which hurts him, you should use an Easy Walk harness.
    Translated from French
    Jean-Yves
    Jean-yves Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    I’m not sure he’ll realise that he’s being shut away just because he jumped on the sofa. If you only punish him every third time he misbehaves, he might understand the very last one if the punishment happens right then and there, but he won’t make the connection with the other times at all. Maybe try buying him a bed that’s much more comfortable than his current basket, especially if he’s been allowed on the bed and the sofa for several months; he’s bound to be quite frustrated now that he’s not allowed on them anymore. It’ll take time. But when you tell him “No!” the moment he tries to get on the sofa, does he not listen to you? And how does he react when you tell him to get down? Does he get down on his own, or do you have to physically move him to get him off?
    Translated from French
    C
    Cannibalkat Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    No more accidents in the house, which is great news! We’ve installed a dog flap so he can go out whenever he likes and it’s working really well. BUT, yes, there’s always a “but”... this dog is so stubborn! He’s started jumping on the sofa again... I’ve had to resort to putting him in time-out (10-15 mins in the bathroom) and then as soon as we let him out, he’s straight back at it... and so on. On Friday night, he kept doing it until I eventually partitioned the room in two. And that wasn't any better; he just barked non-stop in the room... To be honest, I actually had to leave the house for a bit just to clear my head. He’s also started pulling on the lead again, so on the advice of the dog trainer, we’re using a choke chain. It’s a constant battle. We’re staying consistent and keeping calm because there’s no point getting worked up—quite the opposite, in fact—but it is tough going... If anyone has any extra tips, I’d be more than grateful.
    Translated from French
    ?
    Anonymous user Icon representing the flag French
    Report
    I think Mel1 has hit the nail on the head. A happy, and more importantly, well-balanced dog is one that knows its place as a dog! It must feel quite strange for him to realise he can no longer occupy the almost human status he used to have in the household. You need to be consistent with what you’re asking of him (no more getting on the bed, the sofa, etc.). It’ll take a little while, but he should soon understand that the "rules of the game" have changed.
    Translated from French
  • 10 comments out of 23

    See more
  • Do you have a question? An experience to share? Create a post on our forum!